|
ADAM SMITH'S MONEY GAME
Transcript #108
Air Date: June 5, 1998
Missed the show?
Get a phone call half way through? Fail to catch the name of a stock in
"Personal Best"? In case you did, we are happy to provide you with a
transcript. If you would like a transcript from a previous season, please
visit 800-All-News at www.800-all-news.com or call them at (800)
All-News.
ANNOUNCER: [voice over] This program is made possible by a
grant from MetLife, helping people become financially secure for 130
years. Funding has also been provided by the Roy R. and Marie S.
Neuberger Foundation.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] What is this man's secret for running
the world's most glamorous magazine empire? How will TV mogul Ted
Turner make good on his pledge to give away a billion dollars? And
bestselling author Suze Orman on how to build your fortune with your
IRA. Next.
Face to Face
ADAM SMITH: Hello, I'm Adam Smith and welcome to The Money
Game. We all know the mantra ``new media are hot.'' It has become an
overworked cliche, but did you know that some very old fashioned
media are hot too? None more so than glossy magazines. Take Conde
Nast, the company that publishes Vogue, Vanity Fair and the New
Yorker. Privately owned by reclusive billionaire SI Newhouse and the
Newhouse family, Conde Nast may not be number one in sales _ that's
Time Warner _ but it is definitely number one in buzz.
The man charged by Newhouse with managing this hothouse of
oversized egos is Steve Florio, Conde Nast president. Meet Steve
Florio, face to face.
STEVEN FLORIO, President & CEO, CONDE NAST
Publications: People ask me all the time how you get this great,
glamorous job. You run Conde Nast. You deal with all these star
editors. You get to meet all the super models and the great
photographers of the world _ you know, the Dick Avedons _ and all
those things are true. And it is a wonderful way to spend your life, but it
isn't easy.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] The world that Steve Florio runs has
its headquarters in the Conde Nast building on New York's Madison
Avenue. Here, editors and publishers are famous, among other things,
for their high six-figure salaries and generous perks. It is said that when
Florio took up the reins four years ago, the line of limos outside the
door, sometimes stretched around the block.
[on camera] Steve, you took over this company, which had then
nearly a billion dollars in revenue, flashy magazines and outside there
were parked 60 limos. And then what happened?
STEVEN FLORIO: They went.
ADAM SMITH: That's it?
STEVEN FLORIO: The 60 limousines went. It wasn't the 60
limousines so much. What it was, was a way of doing business whose
time had passed. And it was incumbent upon me as the new CEO back
in 19_ January of 1994, to maximize the bottom line of this company.
And I saw T&E budgets that bore no relation to the task at hand, so to
speak. And there were a lot of people that were_
ADAM SMITH: Limousines, Concorde _ that kind_
STEVEN FLORIO: Yeah, limousines, Concordes, you know, fancy
restaurants delivering sandwiches at lunchtime. There was a sense of
obligation that the staff felt the company had towards them. Well, what
we tried to do here at Conde Nast and what hasn't changed is to create
the best possible environment to produce the best possible magazines.
As a result of that, we have had a number of very good years back to
back.
SCOTT DONATON, Managing Editor, AD AGE: His biggest
accomplishment has probably been bringing a financial discipline that
has seen Conde Nast_ they don't report their revenues and their profits,
but in the industry's eyes go from a company that was seen as having
very small profit margins, very low profit margins and profits to very
respectable profits.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] The Conde Nast empire includes
Architectural Digest, Glamour, Mademoiselle, Brides, Self and GQ;
16 titles in all and 17 with the recent acquisition of Wired. But the titles
that get most of the attention in the press are Vogue, The New Yorker
and Vanity Fair. Their editors-in-chief have become celebrities,
especially Anna Winter at Vogue and Tina Brown at The New Yorker,
marketed and promoted almost like movie stars.
I dropped in on another of those Conde Nast stars, Vanity Fair's
editor-in-chief Graydon Carter, who showed me pictures planned for a
piece on TV tycoon Merv Griffin for the June issue. What role, I
wondered, does Steve Florio play in the running of his magazine.
GRAYDON CARTER, Editor, VANITY FAIR: Most of the times
I deal with Steve I'm going to ask him for something and that's
unfortunate. And I mention that to him a lot. It's because I have a
budget here that I rarely ever quite stay to by the end of the year. But
when I have a big idea that's going to go outside the budget, I go to him
and I say to him, ``I'm going to do this. Do you mind?'' And I think in
100 percent of the cases it's been fine.
ADAM SMITH: In this company, unlike many other magazine
companies, your editors become stars, bigger than the writers they
publish. Is that a deliberate policy? How do you create a star?
STEVEN FLORIO: You create a star editor by creating a star
magazine. The New Yorker has won more national magazine awards
than the next three magazines combined. That made Tina Brown a star.
She's been there five years and she's done a very good job.
At Vanity Fair, the same thing has happened. We have a terrific team.
We have Graydon Carter as our editor-in-chief. We have Mitch Fox as
the publisher. And there again, a great team producing an extraordinary
magazine, lots of advertising, lots of awards, readers responding to it,
record circulation. That makes stars.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] And stars love nothing more than one
another's company. So when Carter hosted this year's Vanity Fair
Oscar night party in Los Angeles, most of the Hollywood elite showed
up. But things weren't always this rosy. When he first took over as
editor for Tina Brown, Carter had a hard time finding his feet.
GRAYDON CARTER: When you first take over a magazine it takes,
depending on the size of the magazine, it's either harder or easier than
your previous job. And my first couple of years here was tough.
STEVEN FLORIO: I took Graydon to lunch and I told him to stop
trying to doing Tina's magazine and that he should start to do his
magazine. And that if he brought his voice to it, as all great editors do,
and it worked, then he would take the bow.
GRAYDON CARTER: At Conde Nast, an editor is encouraged to
put their stamp on a magazine, to make the magazine reflect their
personality.
STEVEN FLORIO: What I said to him, in fact, was Gray, you have
something that I will never have as hard as I try _ you have WASPy
good taste. Stop doing Roseanne on the cover, covered in mud. Use
your good taste. Is that a magazine you like? Graydon shook his head.
The next issue we had Meg Ryan on the cover looking absolutely
beautiful, looking like a movie star and a wonderful issue that really
fulfilled the promise of what Graydon Carter's Vanity Fair would be.
GRAYDON CARTER: That I will forever be appreciative to Steve
and SI for because they were only supportive. And I haven't had that
much. In fact, I find it_ the only time that Vanity Fair wasn't making
money they sort of left you alone a lot more than when you are because
all of a sudden there's budget meetings to go to now. Before there
weren't any budget meetings.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] Conde Nast is a hard driving, take no
prisoners kind of place, especially on the publishing side where Steve
Florio began, first at GQ and then for nine years as president of The
New Yorker. However, at the end of the day there are no public
shareholders to answer to, only SI Newhouse and the rest of the
Newhouse family.
[on camera] Do you spend a lot of time together? Do you work
together?
STEVEN FLORIO: With Mr. Newhouse? He's in the office right next
door to me. We spend the day together. We no longer have meetings,
we just spend the day together. He wanders in and out of here
probably 10 times a day. I wander in and out of his office probably 10
times a day. He never drops the gavel and says ``I'm the owner and
that's how we're doing it.'' I've never seen him do it once.
SCOTT DONATON: SI is someone who, if you're sitting right next to
him, you have to strain to hear him. Steve is someone you can hear
from a hundred yards away pretty easily. So Steve probably carries out
and executes the strategy that SI dreams up. But Steve is also his own
player. He came in with very strong views about what Conde Nast
should be, and that's also something that has probably stood him in
good stead with SI Newhouse, which is that he doesn't back down to
him. He's not a ``yes'' man. And I don't think SI Newhouse is looking
for a ``yes'' man.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] To get away from the feverish intensity
of what cynics call Conde Nasty, Florio likes to spend some time in
boats. He recently took charge of a new one which he designed
himself. He is the eldest of three brothers and grew up in New York
City in a close-knit Italian-American family. To remind himself of his
roots and how far he has come, he keeps a framed cartoon on his
office wall.
[on camera] ``My God, Buffy! He's Italian!'' Is it an advantage being
an Italian in this business?
STEVEN FLORIO: I don't know if it's an advantage or disadvantage,
but that was given to me anonymously my first week at The New
Yorker. There were some folks there that were concerned that I might
not have the Mayflower background that they expected in the president
of The New Yorker. And so this was given to me as a great insult. I
took every picture off of the wall in my new office and hung it up. And
it has been in every office since.
When I first started Esquire magazine in the early '70s, I was paraded
around as someone of ethnicity that they were very proud to have
there. The business has changed so much that I don't think anybody
notices anymore. I really don't.
ADAM SMITH: [voice over] Steve is not the only Florio at Conde
Nast. Kid brother Tom works there too, until recently as president and
publisher of The New Yorker. The weekly is said to be losing $11
million a year despite a leap in circulation since Tina Brown arrived.
Some say the red ink is due to high editorial costs said to be $30 million
a year; others, that the persistent losses are due to Conde Nast's
circulation strategy based on increasing the circulation guaranteed to
advertisers while charging them more to advertise. Either way, Tom
Florio recently left The New Yorker to return to his old job as publisher
of Conde Nast Traveler.
Did he leave of his own accord or was he pushed? And what of the
rumors that Tina Brown's contract as editor may not be renewed? So
far no one is talking. I spoke to Steve Florio about sibling rivalry at
Conde Nast a few days before the news about his brother broke.
STEVEN FLORIO: We talk to each other all the time. As far as
meeting socially, well, he's a pretty busy guy; I'm a pretty busy guy. We
don't see each other that often on weekends. He lives in New York. I
live out on Long Island. We spend holidays together, as most brothers
do.
ADAM SMITH: So you've worked out the competition for your
mother's affections?
STEVEN FLORIO: We have indeed. My mother loves me best.
ADAM SMITH: Very good.
[Graphic: Circulation The New Yorker
1992 - 450,000
1998 - 807,000
Up 79%
Source: Audit Bureau of Circulation]
Back to top
On the Spot
ADAM SMITH: There was a time when ad agencies didn't have
public stock. Wall Street said how can you sell something on a
permanent basis, a company, when the assets _ people _ go down in
the elevator every night? Gradually, Wall Street realized that the people
went down in the elevator but advertising in our society is part of daily
life and it isn't going to go away. So ad people found they could
capitalize their own earnings.
Young & Rubicam, 75 years old, is just public. And Bob Garfield is
here to put this giant institution on the spot.
BOB GARFIELD, Columnist, AD AGE: It's a very large _ fifth
largest in the world _ very large, very competent advertising agency, an
agency that actually was known for its research until maybe 10 years
ago and now isn't really known for anything but being kind of a discount
shop. It has gotten enormous account wins by working for lower
commissions and fee structures than other agencies and hasn't been all
that profitable.
On the plus side, though, creatively it has really improved quite
dramatically I would say in the last four or five years.
ADAM SMITH: Let's take a look at one of the Y&R commercials.
They sent us a reel and there is an AT&T campaign that I think is on
now.
BOB GARFIELD: It is on now and it's one of the nicest things on the
air from any agency or any client, anywhere. It's really quite
magnificent.
ADAM SMITH: Let's take a look.
[Excerpt from AT&T commercial]
DAUGHTER, Driving to College Campus: What?
MOTHER: I was taking you to kindergarten last week.
DAUGHTER: Mom, I was born 18 years ago.
MOTHER: Yeah, I know. I was there. I read somewhere that a lot of
kids stay home the first year of college and commute.
DAUGHTER: Mom. You ready?
MOTHER: On three.
DAUGHTER: One, two, three.
MOTHER: Wait for three.
[voice over] FRANK SINATRA, Singing: It's very clear, our love is
here to stay. Not for a year, but ever and a day. In time the Rockies
may crumble, Gibraltar may tumble, they're only made of clay, but our
love is here to stay.
MOTHER: Just checking. HELLO?
DAUGHTER: Just checking.
ADAM SMITH: It's a whole story. I don't know whether to cry or
sign up for a cell phone.
BOB GARFIELD: Well, either way would be fine with AT&T. The
whole idea here, of course, is that they show how these various kinds
of telecommunications technology can fit into your lifestyle. And in this
entire campaign, they have shown these various kinds of rights of
passage _ one's a teen date; one is a Mom who has given up a day at
work to go to the beach with her kids _ and all highlighting the AT&T
products, but most importantly, showing that this big monolithic
corporation understands how you live.
ADAM SMITH: I love the head turn for the nude guy with the towel
wrapped around him.
BOB GARFIELD: What a perfect take. And one of the things that's
great about this campaign is that there's little moments, wonderful
acting, beautifully directed, beautifully edited, that just captures these
little itsy bitsy slices of reality that you seldom see in these so-called
slice of life commercials.
ADAM SMITH: Is there anybody for whom this doesn't bring a lump
in the throat?
BOB GARFIELD: You know, I think the answer is no. I've seen
some pretty hardbitten people kind of choked up by the poignancy of
these spots. And they're not mawkish. They're not sentimental. These
are clearly not utterly dysfunctional families, but they're also not overly
idealized family situations. These are real people in real-life situations
reacting more or less as real people do. And it has really been very well
done from the beginning.
In Focus
ADAM SMITH: When TV mogul Ted Turner took everyone's breath
away last year by announcing he intended to give away a billion dollars
to the U.N., we wondered how do you do that? I mean, when you or I
decide to give $100 to our favorite charity, we just write a check and
mail it. Right? But a billion? Giving away that much has to be different,
maybe even difficult.
Has the cash-starved U.N. seen any of the money yet? If not, when?
We invited Mr. Turner on to our show to enlighten us, but he declined.
Nonetheless, with the help of those who claim to know, my
correspondent Adele Malpass has the story of Ted Turner's billion, in
focus.
ADELE MALPASS, Correspondent: [voice over] He dropped his
bombshell at a United Nations dinner.
TED TURNER, U.N. Dinner: I'm going to try my dead level best to
donate a billion dollars to the U.N. causes myself.
TED TURNER, Larry King Show:I got the idea 48 hours ago.
LARRY KING: And it came how?
TED TURNER: First of all, I looked at my monthly statement,
showed the first of the year. It's got as of January_ December 31st, I
was worth $2.2 billion. And I looked at it that morning real quick,
because I don't have a lot of time to look at my own statement, and it
was up to $3.2 because the stock went up so much during the year. So
I made it in nine months. I'm only giving up nine months' earnings. It's
not that big a deal. I'm no poorer than I was nine months ago and the
world is a lot better off.
ADELE MALPASS: [voice over] Turner's donation is the largest
single charitable pledge ever made and it grabbed headlines around the
world. It was in character _ impulsive, rand and flashy. This is a man
who has been both Time magazine's Man of the Year and called
``Captain Outrageous'' while winning the America's Cup. He, of
course, is best known for transforming his family's billboard company
into CNN.
Turner and his wife, Jane Fonda, have been longtime supporters of the
U.N. His original idea was to not make a donation but to force the U.S.
to pay its debts to the world body.
PORTER BIBB, Banker Ladenburg Thalmann & Co.: We
originally went in last summer and sat with Kofi Annan, the secretary
general, and put an extraordinary proposal on the table. And that
proposal was I'd like to buy the note, the debt, that the United States to
the United Nations so I can walk into the White House and demand
immediate payment or foreclose on the United States. That wasn't
entirely feasible, but it was typical Turner.
ADELE MALPASS: [voice over] As it turns out, Turner is not going
to write a billion dollar check. What he's going to do is donate Time
Warner stock, giving the U.N. $100 million a year over 10 years.
[on camera] The big unknown is how Ted Turner will sell a billion
dollars of his Time Warner stock and how it will affect his position in
the company.
PORTER BIBB: He's not going to sell the shares; that would cost him
hundreds of millions of dollars worth of taxes, capital gains. He's not
going to give the shares to the United Nations, in my opinion, outright
because that would diminish his role as the largest shareholder in Time
Warner. So it's going to be some form of trust or a shadow trust where
the stock appreciation value is matched with cash from his other funds
or other foundations that he has.
ADELE MALPASS: [voice over] So far, not a dime of Turner's
money has actually reached the United Nations. Yet, his impending
donation has already caused unintended consequences. Some say it's a
first step towards privatizing the U.N.
ALVIN ADAMS, President, U.N. Association: It's maybe a note
about the future that the work of the United Nations is not necessarily
totally the preserve of governments and only governments.
ADELE MALPASS: [voice over] Even former Senator Tim Wirth,
now head of Turner's new foundation, is skeptical about privatizing all
U.N. functions.
TIMOTHY WIRTH, President, U.N. Foundation: I think there are
a number of things that government should and would continue to do.
There's no question about the fact that basic refugee programs and
feeding hunger programs and so on are political responsibilities. These
are caused by political problems and ought to be solved by
governments.
ADELE MALPASS: [voice over] If Turner were a country, the
sheer size of his donation would rank him as the fourth largest U.N.
donor nation and larger than all of the African states combined.
[Graphic:
1. United States
2. Japan
3. Germany
4. Ted Turner]
ADELE MALPASS: [on camera] Do you think a large donation by
someone like Ted Turner weakens the U.N.'s democratic mission?
JAMES PAUL, Executive Director, Global Policy Forum: I could
see easily that donations of this kind could push the U.N. in certain
directions that really wouldn't be in accord with the feelings of the
member states. And therefore it, I think, is fundamentally problematical
from a democratic point of view.
TIMOTHY WIRTH: Ted Turner doesn't have a vote. The U.N.
foundation doesn't have a vote. We're doing only what the secretary
general wants to see done.
ADELE MALPASS: With all these difficulties and controversies,
could Ted Turner change his mind?
PORTER BIBB: I don't think there's a snowball's chance in hell that if
the bottom fell out of Time Warner stock tomorrow and it was worth
$10 a share instead of $75 or $80, that he would renege on his
investment. It's just not his nature.
[Graphic: Turner's Gift in Context
The average annual individual charitable contributions: $1,017.
Total U.S. annual charitable contributions: $143 billion.
Source: Independent Sector; Philanthropy in America.]
Back to top
Personal Best
ADAM SMITH: We have heard from many of you about IRAs,
Keough plans and other forms of tax-favored retirement options. Julie
Mitchell from Deep Haven, Minnesota, wonders ``I'm recently married
and my husband and I would like to know the best strategy for saving
with IRAs. Should we both have one? Should we combine our savings?
What is the right thing to do?''
Julie, your signed copy of my book, The Money Game, is in the mail.
And with me now to discuss Julie's question is Suze Orman. We're
happy to welcome Suze to the program to help you do your personal
best.
SUZE ORMAN, Author, ``The 9 Steps to Financial Freedom'':
Should you and your husband have an IRA? Absolutely. What kind of
an IRA? I love these new Roth IRAs. I'm telling you, you can put
money in there. So here, Julie, this is what you need to know.
You and your husband, if you qualify for the income levels and I'm sure
you do because they're quite up there, take your $2,000 a year, put it
into a Roth IRA. Now you're not going to get a tax deduction for it, but
this is what you need to know. In a Roth IRA, you can take that
$2,000 out any time you want without penalty and you don't have to be
59-1/2. You simply have to leave the earnings of that $2,000 in the
account until you're 59-1/2 or at least five years. So if you get in a bind,
if you need something, you can get at that money.
So here you can start saving for your retirement, you can make it be
tax-free as the years go on because Roth IRAs, remember, you don't
get a tax deduction, but when you go to take the money out it's
tax-free. Save for it now. I'm telling you, the money will compound like
you could never believe.
ADAM SMITH: In a Roth IRA, can you put it into whatever you
want?
SUZE ORMAN: Absolutely. You would look to put, especially at
Julie's age _ if you're in your mid-20's, again, go for aggressive growth.
Look for good, no-load mutual funds; ones that don't have a
commission on it. And put your money in there.
A quick example. If you were to put even just $100 a month at the age
of 25 and you did that every single month, so let's say you funded your
IRA with only $1,200 a year, do you know that, Julie, by the time you
were 65 you would have $1 million if that fund returned 12 percent for
you? Wait just 10 years _ don't waste these years, Julie _ wait just 10
years to start, you'd have only $300,000 when you were 65. Don't
wait. Time is of the essence.
[Graphic: Suze Says: If your yearly income is $100,000 or less, you are
allowed to convert all or some of your traditional IRA into a Roth IRA.
Should you convert? To find the answer on-line, contact:
STRONG FUNDS - www.strongfunds.com
T.ROWE FUNDS - www.troweprice.com]
ADAM SMITH: What question would you like answered to help you
do your personal best in the money game? Get in touch with our e-mail
address, letters@adamsmith.net. Or write to us the old-fashioned way
at Adam Smith's Money Game, 885 Third Avenue, Suite 2800, New
York, New York 10022. We look forward to hearing from you. And if
we answer your letter on the air, I'll be sending you a personally signed
copy of my book, The Money Game.
What an age we live in. There was a time when the phrase ``millionaire''
and the songs of Cole Porter denoted lavish wealth. But a million
dollars these days isn't what it used to be. And now we've seen
someone decide to give away a billion dollars because his stock had
gone up by that amount in less than a year. The bull market in stocks
has created a wealth effect, but the gap between the really rich and the
rest of us is widening. Where is that going to take us?
I'm Adam Smith. See you next week as the Money Game continues.
ANNOUNCER: For more of the Money Game, visit us in cyberspace
at www.adamsmith.net.
ANNOUNCER: This program is made possible by a grant from
MetLife with over $330 billion in assets under management. Funding
has also been provided by the Roy R. and Marie S. Neuberger
Foundation.
Back to Top
CREDITS
Editor-in-Chief ADAM SMITH
Executive Producers PETER FOGES and ROBERT J. GELINE
Executive in Charge of Production DOUGLAS P. SINSEL
Associate Producer ELIZABETH D. DEWEY
Produced by ADAM SMITH EDUCATIONAL PRODUCTION
LTD. AND ALLIANCE INTERNATIONAL LLC.
Thanks to:
Gerald J. Austin & Assoc., Inc.
Special thanks to:
Bloomberg: A provider of news and information services worldwide.
3-D Models Provided in Part by 3-D CAFE
For a VHS cassette send $19.95 or $5.00 for a printed transcript to:
Adam Smith's Money Game
800-All-News
1535 Grant Street
Denver, CO 80203
Rush, e-mail or fax charges by credit card, call 1-800-ALL-NEWS.
Copyright _ 1998 Adam Smith Educational Productions Ltd.
The name Adam Smith and the logo of Adam Smith are marks Registered in the United States Patent and Trademark Office. Copyright ©2000 Adam Smith Educational Productions Ltd. |
|